Rate That Song

READ RULES BELOW BEFORE POSTING!!!

Bolded = Important
Bolded + underlined = Very important

-----------------------------------------------------------

Yes. I'm starting a "Rate That Song" thread, but, it doesn't have to be the song above you--ESPECIALLY as the thread grows. This allows metal listeners to rate other metal listeners, "club music" (i.e. trance) listeners to rate other "club music" listeners etc. etc. However, feel free to rate any song you want; but make sure to listen to a majority of it before leaving a rating.

Basically, rate someone's song in the thread (be sure to state WHO'S song you're rating, and WHAT the song is) from 1 to 5. 1, being, the song is fucking horrible (in your opinion), and 5, being, the song is fucking amazing (in your opinion). Feel free to give reasoning behind the rating you gave. BE SURE TO STATE THE GENRE OF THE SONG YOU POST, SO, PEOPLE KNOW AHEAD OF TIME AND CAN SKIP IT IF THEY AREN'T A FAN OF THE GENRE; BE SOMEWHAT SPECIFIC (FOR EXAMPLE: Slayer = Thrash Metal, Skrillex = Dubstep)

I also recommend leaving the video of your song in "spoiler" or "hidden" tags, to prevent lag. YOU CAN LEAVE THE SONG INFORMATION (i.e genre) OUTSIDE THE TAGS THOUGH. Also, for the first page or two, you CAN post a song without rating one first. HOWEVER, come page 3 or 4, you MUST rate a song in order to post one.

I...shall start.

------------------------------------------------------------

The Black Waltz by Kalmah
Genre(s): Melodic death metal, neo-classical metal

Spoiler:

The Laughing Man wrote:

------------------------------------------------------------

The Black Waltz by Kalmah
Genre(s): Melodic death metal, neo-classical metal

3/5. Loved it overall, but the vocals (though meant to be that way) just didn't catch me overall. Music was enjoyable regardless.

Promises by Nero
Genre(s): Dubstep, Electro, Drum 'N' Bass

Spoiler:

Vigo Surai wrote:

Promises by Nero
Genre(s): Dubstep, Electro, Drum 'N' Bass

5 out of 5.

Even though, I, myself, consider myself to be a metalhead, I still really enjoy this type of music--the song you posted is no exception, I remember it from the music thread. I could find very little fault with the song, other than the large lips of the female singer (lolz), hence the "5 out of 5" rating.

Innocent by Rage
Genre(s): Heavy metal, speed metal, power metal

Note: The song OFFICIALLY starts at around 4:00, before that, is the instrumental intro.

Spoiler:

3.5 out of 5.

It is a good performance. Too much powermetal for me. It is great music, but it is not my cup of tea.

Pleasure to Kill by Kreator
Genre(s): Thrash Metal

Spoiler:

TitanT2 wrote:

Pleasure to Kill by [b]Kreator
Genre(s): Thrash Metal

4 out of 5.

I really like Kreator, one of the few thrash metal bands that I do; Onslaught, Sabaton, Slayer, Yyrkoon, and Kreator. Saw them live at Wacken believe it or not, if you can believe I attended Wacken and traveled all the way to Germany. Not one of my favorite songs by them though, hence the "4 out of 5" rating.

Combat by Heaven Shall Burn
Genre(s): Death metal, metalcore, thrash metal

The Laughing Man wrote:

Combat by Heaven Shall Burn
Genre(s): Death metal, metalcore, thrash metal

1.5/5. >.< Didnt much like this one..

Swamped by Lacuna Coil
Genre(s): Rock.

Quote :

A Fine Day to Die by Bathory
Genre(s): Black metal (Quorthon changed his style to Viking doom after the album this was from. Long intro)

2/5. I can't stand Black Metal, and while the beat was OK, the vocals were...no.



Warrior Concerto by The Glitch Mob

Genres: Glitch, Electronic



For added effect:

Step 1: Open Warrior Concerto and pause it.
Step 2: Open it again and play till 30 then play the other one at the same time.
Step 3: Enjoy!

Burkman wrote:

3/5 It's good, but it's not doing it for me for some reason.

Speaking of warriors...

Warrior's Dance by The Prodigy

2/5 i like some songs of The Prodigy this isn't one of them i am afraid

Genres: Swedish Death Metal

Spoiler:

TitanT2 wrote:

2/5 i like some songs of The Prodigy this isn't one of them i am afraid

Genres: Swedish Death Metal

Spoiler:

I really enjoyed it until they started screaming. It just isn't my genre :3 2/5

Animus Vox by The Glitch Mob
Genres: Electronic, Glitch

Burkman wrote:

4/5 I really like this song. Was one of their first songs I've heard.

Good Thoughts, Bad Thoughts by Funkadelic
Genres: P-Funk

3/5 i like the guitars only to calm for me.

Spoiler:

TitanT2 wrote:

Spoiler:

2/5. It scared me :3

Propane Nightmares by Pendulum
Genre: Drum and Bass

Aeraie wrote:

Propane Nightmares by Pendulum
Genre: Drum and Bass

I have raised you well, my child.

5/5.

Still Alive by Mt. Eden
Genre(s):Dubstep

Vigo Surai wrote:

Aeraie wrote:

Propane Nightmares by Pendulum
Genre: Drum and Bass

I have raised you well, my child.

5/5.

Still Alive by Mt. Eden
Genre(s):Dubstep

*wipes tears* Daddy is proud!

4/5, I liked it but felt they could have done a lot more with it.

Pink Lady by Feed Me
Genre: Dubstep

Aeraie wrote:

*wipes tears* Daddy is proud!

4/5, I liked it but felt they could have done a lot more with it.

Pink Lady by Feed Me
Genre: Dubstep

2/5

I don't even...

At the Left Hand ov God by Behemoth (Live Video)

Spoiler:

Brucil wrote:

2/5

I don't even...

At the Left Hand ov God by Behemoth (Live Video)

Spoiler:

5/5 Behemoth \M/

Spoiler:

Aeraie wrote:

Pink Lady by Feed Me
Genre: Dubstep

3/5.

Not bad.

Goddamn these commercials.

Radioactive by Imagine Dragon
Genre: Rock, alt.

Burkman wrote:

Naked Face Down by Rosicrucian

4 out of 5.

My only complaint with the entire song is the singer's voice. It doesn't seem...strong enough for the rest of the song. Maybe that's just because of Youtube's iffy quality.

Demiurge by Meshuggah.
Album: Koloss (2012)
Genre(s): Extreme metal, avant-garde metal, groove metal.

Burkman wrote:

Why you gotta skip mine...

Read the rules again. No need to rate every song above yours. Just whichever seems most appealing.

The Laughing Man wrote:

Burkman wrote:

Naked Face Down by Rosicrucian

4 out of 5.

My only complaint with the entire song is the singer's voice. It doesn't seem...strong enough for the rest of the song. Maybe that's just because of Youtube's iffy quality.

Demiurge by Meshuggah.
Album: Koloss (2012)
Genre(s): Extreme metal, avant-garde metal, groove metal.

3/5
It just seemed like the song was way longer than it needed to be.

To the Edge by Lacuna Coil
Genre: Goth Rock/Metal

Spoiler:

Vigo Surai wrote:

Aeraie wrote:

Pink Lady by Feed Me
Genre: Dubstep

3/5.

Not bad.

Goddamn these commercials.

Radioactive by Imagine Dragon
Genre: Rock, alt.

3/5.

I liked the beat but the vocals just didn't do it for me.

Needle by Dirtyloud
Genres: Dubstep

Burkman wrote:

Vigo Surai wrote:

Burkman wrote:

Why you gotta skip mine...

Read the rules again. No need to rate every song above yours. Just whichever seems most appealing.

Yeah, but if you only rate stuff that seems appealing to your ears, then... what's the point? Anyways...

Aeriae wrote:

Needle by Dirtyloud
Genres: Dubstep

0/5 I hate dubstep with a burning passion. Especially ones with those type of vocals.

At The Gallows End by Candlemass
Genres: Doom Metal

4/5 I like it but it won't stick with me. I like the vocals... But... It kinda is too much opera for me. To clean, lacking a dark vibe. Which i like in my music. Nevertheless good performance.

Spoiler:

TitanT2 wrote:

I Spew Thee Out Of My Mouth by The Monolith Deathcult
Genre: Death Metal/Industrial Death Metal i guess...

5 out of 5

I really liked this song, from its vocals to its instrumentation; it has a cool "vibe" about it. Though... I have never heard of the band before.

Vengeance Rising by Keep of Kalessin
Album: Reptilian (2010)
Genre(s): Extreme metal, blackened death metal, melodic death metal, power metal.

Spoiler:

Burkman wrote:

The Laughing Man wrote:

I think some people are forgetting, that, you DO NOT HAVE TO RATE THE SONG ABOVE YOU; BUT, ANY SONG IN THE THREAD. The reason I made it this way is so you can listen to a song that's in a genre you like (and the reason people should post the genre of the song they are posting), and skip over songs in genres that you don't like. YOU CAN NOT RATE THE SAME SONG TWICE, OF COURSE.

Maybe I WANT to rate the song above me.

I suppose.

But why even bother if you hate the genre to begin with, and, more than likely, automatically give the song a 0 out of 5 rating? You can give a less bias rating by rating a song of the genre you like.

Brucil wrote:

To the Edge by Lacuna Coil
Genre: Goth Rock/Metal

3.5/5

I still prefer Swamped by these guys. But a good song overall.

Brotherhood by John Dreamer
Genre(s): Position Music (think..Soundtrack music. Trailer music. shit like that)